Jump to content


Hynu

Member Since 04 Oct 2006
Offline Last Active Apr 09 2007 09:03 AM

Posts I've Made

In Topic: 300

05 April 2007 - 03:37 PM

Perhaps the most unpleasant thing I got was that only Greeks were allowed to be the good guys.  Among the bad guys we had Persians, blacks, arabs, disfigured people and an androgynous god-king.  It kinda left a bad taste in my mouth.  On the other hand, I think Ephialtes definitely made the right choice: would you rather stick with the uptight, fascistic Spartans, or the Persians with ungodly gorgeous whores who almost seemed turned on by your grotesque appearance?  I know what hat I'd be wearing.


This was my feeling exactly: Xerxes most definitely organised the best parties!  I'm not surprised it's p*ssed off the Iranians - those Mullahs would never allow them that much fun...

The overall effect is that the movie is going to send me back to the history books - in fact I would rather had more historical accuracy than the comic book elements.  Xerxes was pure camp, and it certainly seemed after a while that we had tumbled through a gap in the space-time continuum into Middle-Earth - with Haradhrim, Orcs, Trolls and even oliphaunts on the rampage, mixed up somehow with the occupants of a travelling circus-cum-vaudeville sideshow.   The much-trumpeted violence was of the video-arcade variety with (as Scott Oden has noted on his blog) minimum blood.  Someone can be beheaded in slow-motion with not so much as a spurt.  I'm no gorehound, but this stuck out like a sore thumb!

I don't begrudge the ticket price, and I might even buy the dvd if I saw it in a sale, but really this was a bit of a disappointment overall.  But all good fun if you're not too bothered about historical accuracy or non-PCness.


I went into it telling myself not to get hung up on the historical inaccuracies.  I pretty much knew it'd be heavily cheesed, and the artsy fartsy sex scene was unnecessary too (even though shes a fit lass ofcourse ;) ).  Thought it was a fun view aslong as its taken with a pinch of salt.  

I have seen another film based on this same battle, though much older, it must be a 50's to 60's version.  Anybody know the name of it?

In Topic: Recommended Fantasy Books

05 April 2007 - 03:33 PM

I'm still waiting for the next one. I really didn't like how he split the story in the latest book. All my preferred characters are in the as yet unpublished one! ;)

In Topic: Howard Phillips Lovecraft: Master of Horror

05 April 2007 - 03:32 PM

I've come across some of the Lovecraft stuff on the internet, but I find I really struggle to read for any length of time from off of my monitor.  Will have to purchase me thinks.  You cant beat the feel of a nice new book in your grubby palms ;)