Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 12 January 2011 - 06:34 PM.
Posted 09 January 2011 - 01:24 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 12 January 2011 - 06:34 PM.
Posted 09 January 2011 - 10:42 PM
Is that how you really view that sentence? So what are these multiple non-black countries? Let's speculate that Negari can be one setting aside problematic placement in Africa that Rippke states: "Negari is described as lying inland from the western Slave Coast of Africa; an area that was submerged beneath the sea during the Hyborian Age", and an incompatible time-line in Moon of Skulls that would not coincide with The Hyborean Age or anything in the Conan stories. What are the others? Let's say for argument's sake non-human servants of Bit-Yakin have their own country as well. It boggles me that you believe Conan is referring to gray hairy devils and an elusive brown skin race that he never mentions visiting countries or kingdoms of.
I have made my arguments and it is obvious that I cannot change Deuce's or your mind. I must admit it is unlikely that you will change mine either, but I am not saying "NO WAY" to a possibility however remote and would love to hear your quote based arguments supporting placement and existence of kingdoms and countries now.
I found Taranaich's map. It looks like there are several threads for me still to read on these boards.
It looks pretty cool. Although the black kingdoms of the Amazons, Kush, Atlaia, and Zimbabwei don't look very "vast" at all.
Robert E. Howard, 1906 - 2006
Sword & Sorcery!
Historical Fiction!
Horror!
Westerns!
Boxing!
Conan!
Posted 09 January 2011 - 11:50 PM
Is that how you really view that sentence? So what are these multiple non-black countries? Let's speculate that Negari can be one setting aside problematic placement in Africa that Rippke states: "Negari is described as lying inland from the western Slave Coast of Africa; an area that was submerged beneath the sea during the Hyborian Age", and an incompatible time-line in Moon of Skulls that would not coincide with The Hyborean Age or anything in the Conan stories. What are the others? Let's say for argument's sake non-human servants of Bit-Yakin have their own country as well. It boggles me that you believe Conan is referring to gray hairy devils and an elusive brown skin race that he never mentions visiting countries or kingdoms of.
Why not? There are a lot of amazing things Conan has seen and incredible places he's been to that he never mentions in other stories. He never mentions talking with an alien being from the planet Yag, for instance: nor does he mention an island inhabited by a race of black-skinned monsters, or a kingdom ruled by a gigantic living iron statue. Kingdoms of gray hairy devils and elusive brown races wouldn't be that much more amazing.I have made my arguments and it is obvious that I cannot change Deuce's or your mind. I must admit it is unlikely that you will change mine either, but I am not saying "NO WAY" to a possibility however remote and would love to hear your quote based arguments supporting placement and existence of kingdoms and countries now.
Sure thing: I had been happy to consider the "unknown countries south of the black kingdoms" sufficient, but I'm positive there's more to it than that.I found Taranaich's map. It looks like there are several threads for me still to read on these boards.
It looks pretty cool. Although the black kingdoms of the Amazons, Kush, Atlaia, and Zimbabwei don't look very "vast" at all.
Heh, yeah, that's an ooooooold map, and I've long since abandoned any attempt to map out anything beyond what Howard described. It's based on Dale's map, and I definitely agree that they don't look particularly vast. I've reconsidered a lot of things since then.
LOVE the updated map, by the way. I still disagree in regards to the Black Kingdoms question, but aside from that, everything looks fantastic. Very appreciative you shifted Zamboula, too.
In addition to mapping out territories, it might be worth looking for hints about the geographical features, and possibly tying them into modern geography.
Blue Mountains = The Jan Mayen Microcontinent raised up, before being pushed back down in the Ice Age?
Crom's Mountain (possibly mythical) = The Shetland or Orkney Islands raised to mountain status? The Jotunheimen of southern Scandinavia?
Kothian Escarpment = Greece/Italy mountains, Mediterranean shelf
Zamorian Mountains = No parallel. Presumably these mountains were lost by the dawn of modern history...
Hyrkanian Mountains = Altai Mountains
Vilayet Mountains = Urals
Poitanian Mountains = Pyrenees
Western Cimmerian Mountains = England/Scotland/Ireland (possibly the Mountains of the Dead of Pictish mythology?)
Mountains of the Nestor Fragment = Zamorian Mountains?
Himelian Mountains = Himalayas
Ghulistan Mountains = Hindu Kush
Border Range (Aquilonia/Nemedia) = Alps
Flaming Mountains of Khrosha = "Flaming Mountains" seems to indicate volcanic activity. You placed it in eastern Koth, near the Carpathians: do they have a history of volcanic activity? If not, perhaps somewhere in the Italian/Greek areas with volcanos: the Phlegraean Fields and Vesuvius are on the border of Koth & Shem. Maybe relocate Khrosha to there?
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 30 September 2012 - 08:11 PM.
Posted 10 January 2011 - 02:59 AM
How would I incorporate your idea of tying in geographical features on the map? The Carpathians has volcanoes probably dormant currently but I like the idea of Vesuvius better, I'll need to change that.
Have you considered by my estimate Kush includes these black kingdoms (the majority being tribes each with their own king):
Shumballa - Mad degenerate King + sister Tanada may be the capital of all Kush but the Chagas can barely reign in the Gallahs
Keshia - irascible King
Tombalku - King Sakumbe, King Zehbeh
Bakalah - King Bajujh
Jihiji - rivals to Bakalah
Abombi - King Ajaga
Xuchotl - King Olmec
Xuthal - Probably a king if anyone is awake long enough to care
Gazal - Probably a king or the vampires are the rulers
Tribes we know of by name only but probably have kings, warchiefs, or other ruling heads even if they pay tribute to larger kingdoms:
Bamula
Bornu
Mandingo
Bagirmi
Dongola
Suba
Tibu
Ghanata
Kordafan may be a kingdom itself or a city either way it is likely to have a king just as the port city of Abombi does.
Zabhela for the same reason being a port city likely has one as well.
At least 9 known or most probable kingdoms, with 8 likely tribal kings plus two others makes at least 19 probable kingdoms in Kush.
Is it really so preposterous that the black kingdoms of Kush are just that the black kingdoms of Kush; and the unknown countries as Howard put it "countries Hyborians are ignorant of" include Atlaia, Zimbabwei, Amazons, and Punt?
Do you really discount all of the possibilities I have put forth as not possible? With the only possibility being a country of brown-skinned people or non-humanoid servants?
"I?ve roamed in the unknown countries south of the black kingdoms of Kush, and east of the Sea of Vilayet." - Beyond the Black River
Robert E. Howard, 1906 - 2006
Sword & Sorcery!
Historical Fiction!
Horror!
Westerns!
Boxing!
Conan!
Posted 10 January 2011 - 04:06 AM
That's fine Taranaich. So how would you and Deuce map out the southern black kingdoms?
"I’ve roamed in the unknown countries south of the black kingdoms of Kush, and east of the Sea of Vilayet." - Beyond the Black River
I've roamed in the unknown (not known to anyone Hyborian or not, unmentioned, no stories) countries (plural as in more than one) of brown-skinned peoples that are south of the black kingdoms of Kush (Keshan, Darfar, Punt, Kush proper), and I roamed east of the Sea of Vilayet.
Is that how you really view that sentence? So what are these multiple non-black countries? Let's speculate that Negari can be one setting aside problematic placement in Africa that Rippke states: "Negari is described as lying inland from the western Slave Coast of Africa; an area that was submerged beneath the sea during the Hyborian Age", and an incompatible time-line in Moon of Skulls that would not coincide with The Hyborean Age or anything in the Conan stories. What are the others? Let's say for argument's sake non-human servants of Bit-Yakin have their own country as well. It boggles me that you believe Conan is referring to gray hairy devils and an elusive brown skin race that he never mentions visiting countries or kingdoms of.
"I’ve roamed in the unknown countries south of the black kingdoms of Kush, and east of the Sea of Vilayet." - Beyond the Black River
I view this sentence this way, with two geographic place names separated by a comma but sharing the action verb "roamed" and the descriptive adjective "unknown", with the conjunction "and" serving as a connector between the common clause "I've roamed in these countries:
I've roamed in the unknown countries south of the black kingdoms of Kush.(and) I've roamed in the unknown countries east of the Sea of Vilayet.
I have stated that I think it is a possibility that there are brown-skinned peoples south of Kush. There are several mentions of them with the current tribes mixing with them and still at least the women of The Vale of Lost Women that are not mixed.
I do not discount the possibility of a brown non ne groid race south of Kush, but do not think he is referring to them and there is no mention of his traveling to a country of them, not to say it couldn't have happened just that it is not chronicled. It would be cool indeed if it was as more Conan stories by Howard would be awesome regardless of locality.
But Deuce seems to think there is no possibility of conceding that even if they exist Conan is not referring to them.
Even though I have given several possibilities in the other thread: such as Howard referring to earlier published stories for the fans, Conan referring to places we know he has visited from prior stories, kingdoms of Kush being plural in this instance because it includes Keshia because it is claimed by Kush being a hinterland, Howards quote being in two parts one referencing Kush to the Black Coasts or coastal region the "whole southern coast" making it impossible to have unknown kingdoms south of the the whole southern coast, and the other part in reference to a hyborian's ignorant view of people from the black kingdoms, the fact that Conan is not a Hyborian and said quote wouldn't apply to him anyways as to how he would name nations or call the peoples (In every Conan tale he correctly names the black countries and black peoples and distinguishes them by name and features), the word countries meaning not necessarily ruled by a government but referring to an alternate definition that countries mean lands or countrysides, a breakdown of the sentence per English grammar including sentence parts, structure, and punctuation, the fact that the sentence indicates the "roamed in the unknown countries" clause is shared between the area south of the black kingdoms of Kush and additional unknown countries east of the sea of Vilayet based on sentence structure, The Hyborian Age mentions the Cimmerians, nordics and the Hyborian nations as descendants of the Atlanteans supported by Conan stories with wizards from Archeron saying they fought Conan's ancestors of old contradicting the Solomon Kane Atlanteans settling in Africa and being brown-skinned, etc.
But none of those in any way is a possibility for Deuce preferring over any of those more simple theories a speculative one that Conan is referring to unknown, unchronicled adventures in some non-black kingdom (which is a possibility, however remote). All because of my explanation of this quote:
"‘I’ve roamed far; farther than any other man of my race ever wandered. I’ve seen all the great cities of the Hyborians, the Shemites, the Stygians and the Hyrkanians. I’ve roamed in the unknown countries south of the black kingdoms of Kush, and east of the Sea of Vilayet. I’ve been a mercenary captain, a corsair, a kozak, a penniless vagabond, a general – hell, I’ve been everything except a king, and I may be that, before I die.’ The fancy pleased him, and he grinned hardly. Then he shrugged his shoulders and stretched his mighty figure on the rocks. ‘This is as good life as any. I don’t know how long I’ll stay on the frontier; a week, a month, a year. I have a roving foot. But it’s as well on the border as anywhere.’” – Beyond the Black River
With my explanation:
"Conan is stating that he has been in all the great cities of the Hyborians. It would be interesting to know what is considered a great city and if some Hyborian nations like The Border Kingdom have any. By this time in his life he has been to Hyperborea, Brythunia, Nemedia, Zamora, Corinthia, Ophir, Aquilonia, Zingara, Argos, Koth, Khoraja, and Khauran of the Hyborian kingdoms. He has been in the land of Shem, and also among the Stygians in the ancient realm of Stygia. By this statement it seems he has also been in Hyrkania possibly as a Kozak, but had definitely seen some of the Hyrkanian’s great cities in the empire of Turan in addition to those he might have seen east of the Sea of Vilayet. Conan states he has been in the unknown countries south of Kush, possibly meaning unknown to Hyborians, having traveled to Keshan and Punt. He has been in the Himelias and Vendhya."
- The Chronicles of Conan the Cimmerian
The funny thing is it has no bearing whatsoever on my chronology whether the statement is supportive of a visit to Keshia and Punt and Deuce agrees.More cool stuff. While I might quibble about specific points, you're definitely doing some great work here, Amra.
BTW, I have no problem with your placement of "Servants" or with your theory about when Conan was in Keshan and Punt. However, I simply can't see how the passage in question backs up that particular bit of speculation.
IMO, it's possible that Conan went through Keshan and Punt at some point in his career, but there is NO WAY that the "unknown countries" refer to those kingdoms.
All placement of the kingdoms south of Howard's maps are purely speculative and conjectural in nature, being the case I am open to ideas of how they can be placed and will be interested to see Deuce and your theories supporting compelling reasons for a brown-skinned race south of Kush, and placements for any and all of the black kingdoms and non-black kingdoms on the Stygian continent.There's no compelling reason to argue against a brown race surviving somewhere south of Xuchotl. "MoS" argues for it. Howard and HPL both believed there was such a race which predated the black peoples (and the KhoiSan) in southern Africa. They discussed it in their correspondence. It is generally believed now that blacks/Negroids didn't penetrate into the southern third of Africa until the Christian era. So, having a non-black population in that region during the Hyborian era violates neither REH's beliefs or current scientific knowledge.
Deuce is saying that south of the black kingdoms are other kingdoms not of black origin on the main continent. If you imagine the landmass as resembling Africa, Deuce is suggesting that the black kingdoms only extend to, purely as an example, the Tropic of Capricorn; south of the tropic are "countries south of the black kingdoms."
I have made my arguments and it is obvious that I cannot change Deuce's or your mind. I must admit it is unlikely that you will change mine either, but I am not saying "NO WAY" to a possibility however remote and would love to hear your quote based arguments supporting placement and existence of kingdoms and countries now.
Oh and I moved Zamboula up for you and it is still in line with the arrow on Howard's 1936 map.
Edited by grim cimmerian, 10 January 2011 - 04:16 AM.
Posted 10 January 2011 - 04:28 AM
I've roamed in the unknown countries south of the black kingdoms of Kush, and east of the Sea of Vilayet.
"I saw it carved in the rock of a cave no human had visited for a million years," muttered Conan. "In the uninhabited mountains beyond the Sea of Vilayet, half a world away from this spot. Later I saw a black witch-finder of Kush scratch it in the sand of a nameless river.
Is it merely coincidence that Howard mentioned Conan traveling to the extreme east and south, and then calling upon experiences in those regions? If so, "east of the Sea of Vilayet" could well mean "the uninhabited mountains beyond the Sea of Vilayet" (presumably the mountains which rose up in the centre of Hyrkania, as mentioned in THA). The black witch-finder of Kush could be a fellow adventurer who ended up in that same unknown kingdom: Howard did mention it was a nameless river.
It doesn't shed that much light on the subject of the unknown countries, but I thought it worth pointing out.
It's an interesting setup, and could indeed be something along the lines of Asgard/Vanaheim/Cimmeria: however, it's that "capital of Kush" line that bothers me. If Kush is the capital, and the other tribes are little kingdoms, then wouldn't the ruler of Kush be an emperor? Plus Kush is more advanced, socially speaking, than the northern barbarians are: the Nordheimer live in tents, while Shumballa has palaces, gardens and a great square.
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 10 January 2011 - 10:14 PM.
Posted 10 January 2011 - 07:09 AM
As you say, "east of the Sea of Vilayet" could easily just be a reference to Vendhya and Ghulistan - however, upon rereading I noticed an interesting correlation with a moment later in the story:
I've roamed in the unknown countries south of the black kingdoms of Kush, and east of the Sea of Vilayet.
"I saw it carved in the rock of a cave no human had visited for a million years," muttered Conan. "In the uninhabited mountains beyond the Sea of Vilayet, half a world away from this spot. Later I saw a black witch-finder of Kush scratch it in the sand of a nameless river.
Is it merely coincidence that Howard mentioned Conan traveling to the extreme east and south, and then calling upon experiences in those regions? If so, "east of the Sea of Vilayet" could well mean "the uninhabited mountains beyond the Sea of Vilayet" (presumably the mountains which rose up in the centre of Hyrkania, as mentioned in THA). The black witch-finder of Kush could be a fellow adventurer who ended up in that same unknown kingdom: Howard did mention it was a nameless river.
It doesn't shed that much light on the subject of the unknown countries, but I thought it worth pointing out.
I think the biggest sticking point is the emphasis on unknown, for me at least.
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 10 January 2011 - 05:31 PM.
Posted 12 January 2011 - 07:20 AM
however, upon rereading I noticed an interesting correlation with a moment later in the story:
I've roamed in the unknown countries south of the black kingdoms of Kush, and east of the Sea of Vilayet.
"I saw it carved in the rock of a cave no human had visited for a million years," muttered Conan. "In the uninhabited mountains beyond the Sea of Vilayet, half a world away from this spot. Later I saw a black witch-finder of Kush scratch it in the sand of a nameless river.
Is it merely coincidence that Howard mentioned Conan traveling to the extreme east and south, and then calling upon experiences in those regions? If so, "east of the Sea of Vilayet" could well mean "the uninhabited mountains beyond the Sea of Vilayet" (presumably the mountains which rose up in the centre of Hyrkania, as mentioned in THA). The black witch-finder of Kush could be a fellow adventurer who ended up in that same unknown kingdom: Howard did mention it was a nameless river.
It doesn't shed that much light on the subject of the unknown countries, but I thought it worth pointing out.
Just one story left, and it's a doozy!
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 12 January 2011 - 08:12 AM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:11 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 13 January 2011 - 11:50 PM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:16 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 01 September 2011 - 03:51 PM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:23 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 17 January 2011 - 05:36 AM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:27 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 16 January 2011 - 10:35 PM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:30 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 19 September 2011 - 03:51 PM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:34 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 14 January 2011 - 07:16 AM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:38 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 14 January 2011 - 01:00 AM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:41 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 14 January 2011 - 01:00 AM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:45 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 14 January 2011 - 07:23 AM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:49 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 14 January 2011 - 01:01 AM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:52 PM
Edited by Amra_the_Lion, 17 January 2011 - 05:46 AM.
Posted 13 January 2011 - 05:53 PM